Waukesha County Storefront

21430 W Greenfield Ave. Ste #3
New Berlin, WI 53146

Your Local Mobile Locksmith

Convenient mobile locksmith service in the Milwaukee, WI metro region.

Mobile Service Hours

We’re here for you 7 days a week
Mon-Sun: 5am to 11pm

Affordable Locksmith Blog

Why You Should Rekey Your Milwaukee Home After Moving In

by | Jun 25, 2025 | Home Security

Moving into a new home in Milwaukee comes with a long checklist. You change your address, set up utilities, and learn the new routines for your street and neighborhood. Your door locks should also be on that list, because you cannot know how many copies of the old key exist.

At Affordable Locksmith LLC, we rekey house locks throughout Milwaukee and its surrounding communities. We help new homeowners, condo buyers, and renters reset access so the previous key no longer works. Rekeying gives you precise control over who can enter your home, allowing you to start fresh on day one.

What Rekeying Means for Your Door Locks

Rekeying changes the internal pins inside the lock cylinder. The lock retains the same exterior hardware, but it operates with a new key. Your old key will stop working as soon as we complete the rekeying process.

This option works well when the lock hardware still operates correctly. Rekeying also helps when you want one key to work on multiple locks, as long as the locks share a compatible brand and keyway. We inspect each lock on-site and inform you of what is possible before we begin.

Why Rekeying Matters Right After You Move In

Most homes have a long key history. Real estate lockboxes, past owners, family members, dog walkers, cleaners, and contractors can all add copies to the mix. Even when everyone acts in good faith, keys spread over time and you lose track of who has them.

Rekeying solves that problem in a direct way. You keep your current door locks, but you remove access from every old key that may still be out there. Many Milwaukee homeowners also choose rekeying after a remodel, after a roommate moves out, or after a key goes missing during a move.

Here are common reasons new Milwaukee homeowners ask us to rekey locks:

  • You received several keys at closing and you do not know which copies still exist
  • You found a hidden spare key outside and you cannot confirm who placed it
  • You hired movers or contractors and you want to reset access afterward
  • You bought a rental property and you want clean key control before a tenant moves in
  • You want all exterior doors set to the same key for daily convenience

These reasons apply to condos, duplexes, and single-family homes. They also apply to households that share keys with family members who visit often.

Which Doors You Should Rekey First

Many people think about the front door only, but most homes have more than one entry point. A side door, garage entry, or back door can become the “daily use” door once you settle in. We help you identify the doors that matter, so you don’t leave one lock on an old key.

Most homeowners include these door locks in a move-in rekey:

  • Front entry door deadbolt and knob or lever
  • Side or back entry doors
  • Door from the garage into the home
  • Basement service doors, if the door has an exterior lock
  • Patio doors with a keyed cylinder, if the hardware supports rekeying

After we review your doors, we can group compatible locks onto the same key. If a lock does not match the rest, we can discuss lock replacement or lock installation options that fit the door and your goals.

What to Expect During a Rekey Service Visit

We begin by asking about the type of home you have and the number of doors you want to secure. We also ask if you want one key for all locks or separate keys for specific doors. This helps us plan the right parts and the right number of new keys.

When we arrive, we verify access and inspect each lock. We remove the lock cylinder, replace the old pins with new pins, and set the key plug to your new key. We then test the lock for smooth turning and proper latching, and we confirm that the old key no longer works. If we find worn hardware or alignment issues, we explain what we see and what change will restore reliable use.

Rekey vs. Replace for a New Home

Rekeying is a strong first step when the lock still works and the door closes correctly. Replacement is the better choice when the lock is damaged, the cylinder is worn, or the door hardware no longer fits the door. We see this in older Milwaukee homes, where doors shift over time or where hardware has been subjected to heavy use.

We help you decide based on function, not guesswork. If your lock sticks, the key binds, or the latch fails to catch, we may recommend lock repair or lock replacement instead of rekeying. That approach helps you avoid repeat problems and keeps your entry secure.

Rekeying Also Helps With Daily Convenience

A new home often means multiple people need access right away. Rekeying provides a clean start, and it also allows you to plan how you want keys to function in your household. Many homeowners want one key for all exterior doors, then separate keys for interior privacy locks or storage areas.

We can also cut spare keys during the same visit when you request them. That step helps reduce future lockouts and keeps access simple for family members, trusted neighbors, or property managers.

Start Your Move-In With Clear Key Control

Your new home should feel like your own, and your door locks play a significant role in that sense of belonging. Rekeying removes uncertainty and gives you a clear, practical security upgrade without changing the look of your doors. We help Milwaukee homeowners set up new keys, confirm the lock function, and ensure every important entry point locks as it should.

If you want to rekey your Milwaukee home after moving in, contact us today to schedule an appointment for our convenient mobile service, which comes to you. We will ask a few questions, then we will arrive ready to reset your locks and help you move in with confidence.